Death benefit dilemmas: trustee discretion and AFCA’s approach to law and fact
Recent cases demonstrating how AFCA re‑weighs evidence, wishes and dependency with less formal fact-finding processes.
By Darryl Browne - 1 min readRecent cases demonstrating how AFCA re‑weighs evidence, wishes and dependency with less formal fact-finding processes.
By Darryl Browne - 1 min readHow the ‘permitted general situation’ exception was applied using the framework of suitability, alternatives and proportionality.
By Sarah Sacher - 2 min readHow a knowing failure to read mandatory material was enough to satisfy the demanding mental element of the notoriously difficult-to-prove tort.
By Ellen Rock - 2 min readRecent decisions discuss the Hearne v Street obligation and the strict expectations on independence, representation and procedural fairness in complex litigation.
By Dr David J. Townsend and Paris Hart - 12 min readThe courts clarify preliminary judicial comments, access to court documents, the reach of personal protection orders and the evidence needed for significant costs awards.
By Craig Nicol and Keleigh Robinson - 1 min readWhen do facts undermine jurisdiction? And when does a plea deliver more than mere utility? These decisions give practitioners clearer guardrails on both fronts.
By Thomas Spohr - 1 min readDiscussion of key principles on relevance for disclosure, rebutting revocation presumptions, identifying testamentary intent, estoppel and family provision relief.
By Darryl Browne - 2 min readJudicial scepticism, fractured reasoning and shifting tests marked 2025, leaving the implied freedom’s coherence and future direction in question.
By Dr Jemimah Roberts and Dr Shireen Morris - 1 min readRukhadze underscores the strictness of fiduciary accountability and signals little appetite for reform in either the UK or Australia.
By Theresa Power - 2 min readThe rise of conduct‑based disclaimers shows why executors must document communications carefully and why wills require explicit provisions.
By Mary-Ann de Mestre - 1 min readExpert evidence, collateral information and practitioner insight together form the foundation of a defensible capacity assessment in civil proceedings.
By Alex Morrison - 2 min readSweeping amendments—new objects, new authorities and streamlined pathways—reorient the NSW planning system toward proportionality, productivity and housing.
By Anneliese Korber and Phoebe Saxon - 1 min readDelayed diagnosis leaves families unprepared for legal decisions, highlighting the need for structured guidance on planning, supports and capacity.
By Professor Nola Ries and Associate Professor Fiona Kumfor - 1 min read